Black Friday VIP: sign-ups for the list are open. Join the VIP list
Version françaiseDC Club loginBook your member treatmentsTreatmentsConcernsConditionsFor menOffersThe guide for women
See moreShopAboutThe teamBlog
← The DC JournalTips

Don't Recognize Yourself in Your Tattoo Anymore? Touch-Up, Cover-Up or Removal: What Exists, and How to Choose

Touch-up, cover-up or removal: three paths depending on what really bothers you about your tattoo, and how to tell which one is truly yours.

Forearm with an old black tribal tattoo, its lines greyed and faded, against a beige background, in Laval

If you regret your tattoo, three paths exist: touch it up, cover it with another design, or remove it, partly or completely. The right choice depends less on the tattoo itself than on what bothers you about it.

You look at it in the mirror after a shower, you hide it under a sleeve in the summer, or you have simply stopped recognizing yourself in it. Nothing to be ashamed of: it's a common situation, and it has solutions.

This article helps you name what's wrong, walks through each option and what it takes, and ends with a grid to figure out which one is yours.

Regret isn't always the same problem

"I regret my tattoo" can mean four very different things. Before choosing an option, it's worth knowing which one is yours.

  • The technique went wrong. The lines are shaky, the shading is uneven, a letter is badly formed. You still like the design; it's the execution that bothers you.
  • You no longer like the design. The style feels dated to you, the motif doesn't look like you anymore. It's well done, but it isn't you.
  • The meaning has changed. A name, a date, a symbol tied to a period of your life you've left behind.
  • The tattoo has aged. The outlines are less crisp than on day one, the colours have faded, and the whole thing has lost its sharpness.

A survey of 196 people seeking tattoo removal at four American dermatology clinics (Armstrong et al., Archives of Dermatology, 2008) listed the reasons most often given: simply deciding to get rid of it, embarrassment, a body image that suffered, and a new job or career. The authors concluded that removal went along with a shift in identity, a way of distancing oneself from the past.

The survey only covers people who were already seeking removal. It doesn't say how many tattooed people regret their tattoo, so we won't give you a percentage. What it shows is that the reasons vary, and that they call for different answers.

Forearm with a fine black and grey tattoo of mountains and fir trees, next to a white sleeve

First option: the touch-up, when you still like the design

If it's the execution that bothers you and you still like the design, a touch-up is often the shortest path. A tattoo artist goes over the lines, fixes the shading, revives a colour that has faded.

A touch-up fits two situations well:

  • a well-designed tattoo where some lines healed poorly or faded;
  • a tattoo that has lost its sharpness over the years, and that you'd like to see as it was.

It doesn't fit when it's the design itself that no longer looks like you. Going over a motif you don't like anymore makes it more visible.

A touch-up is done by a tattoo artist. It's not a treatment we offer: if that's what suits you, we'll tell you plainly.

Second option: the cover-up, when you want a different design instead

A cover-up means tattooing a new design over the old one. It's the option for people who still like being tattooed, just not with that motif.

A cover-up has a constraint people don't always see coming: the old ink stays in the skin, under the new design. The darker and denser the old tattoo, the less freedom the artist has for the new one. A light, fine or very detailed motif is hard to place over a dark base.

That's why a tattoo artist sometimes asks for the old design to be lightened before covering it. A paler tattoo underneath leaves more choice for the one going on top. We explain it in detail in our article on what to know before a cover-up.

It's up to the artist to judge whether your old tattoo can be covered as it is or needs lightening first. Their opinion comes before ours on that question.

Third option: removal, partial or complete

When you don't want any tattoo at all in that spot, or when a cover-up needs lightening first, removal comes in. It's done with a laser, over several spaced-out sessions.

According to the American Academy of Dermatology, a laser cannot safely break down all the layers of ink in a single session. Your body also needs time to flush out the broken-up ink between sessions. The tattoo lightens after each session.

Removal comes in two forms:

  • Partial removal, which lightens the tattoo without aiming to make it disappear. It mostly serves to prepare a cover-up, or to make a tattoo more discreet.
  • Complete removal, which aims to clear as much ink as possible.

It has to be said clearly: complete removal is never guaranteed. Cleveland Clinic notes that it's fairly common for removal not to clear a tattoo entirely, because some colours resist and some pigment sits too deep. The number of sessions, and what you can hope for with your tattoo, are discussed at the assessment, after we've seen it.

The right choice depends less on the tattoo itself than on what bothers you about it.

The grid: your problem, the option that fits, what it takes

What bothers youThe option that usually fitsWhat it takes
Poorly healed lines, uneven shading, but you like the designTouch-upAn appointment with a tattoo artist
A tattoo that has faded or lost its sharpness, and that you still loveTouch-upAn artist willing to rework the existing design
A design you no longer like, but you want to stay tattooedCover-upA new design, drawn by the artist to cover the old one
An old tattoo too dark to be covered as it isPartial removal, then cover-upA few laser sessions to lighten, then the artist
A meaning that has changed, and you want nothing in that spotComplete removalA series of spaced-out sessions, with no guarantee of full clearance
You're still unsureWait, and learn moreNothing but time to think it over

The same tattoo can fall into two rows. A name that means nothing to you anymore, on an otherwise well-done tattoo, can be covered as easily as removed: it all depends on what you want to see in that spot ten years from now.

Outstretched forearm with a black and grey floral tattoo from the wrist to mid-arm, on a beige background

What time changes, and what it doesn't

Does regret fade with time? Sometimes. A tattoo that bothers you at 25 can become a memory you own at 40, and the reverse happens too. Nobody can tell you in advance which way yours will go.

What time doesn't change is the ink itself. A tattoo doesn't disappear on its own. It can fade and lose sharpness, which sometimes makes it easier to cover, but it stays.

If you're unsure, there's no rush. Waiting is an option in its own right, and it closes no doors: all three paths will still be open in six months. What we advise against is deciding in the heat of the moment, in either direction.

Two situations do call for a little more thought before acting:

  • A recent tattoo, still healing. The skin needs time before anyone thinks of covering or lightening it.
  • A cover-up project, which is planned by first talking with the artist who will do the new design.

How to know which one is yours

Ask yourself three questions, in this order.

  1. Do I still like the design? If yes, look at a touch-up. If not, go to the next question.
  2. Do I still want a tattoo in that spot? If yes, a cover-up is probably your path, with lightening first if the old design is dark. If not, it's removal.
  3. Am I ready to give it time? A cover-up is planned with an artist; removal is done over several spaced-out sessions. Both take patience.

Sometimes people leave an assessment with the answer "keep it". A tattoo that barely bothers you, that's easy to hide, or whose removal would take more than you're willing to put in, doesn't always need treatment. We'll tell you that too.

One question remains once you've chosen your path: if it's removal or lightening, what will decide the number of sessions for your own tattoo? The page on unwanted tattoos answers that one.

Questions we are asked

Does regret go away with time?

Sometimes, and nobody can predict it. What doesn't go away is the ink: a tattoo can fade, but it doesn't leave on its own. Waiting remains an option that closes no doors.

Do I have to remove it, or is a cover-up often enough?

If you still want a tattoo in that spot, a cover-up is often enough. It sometimes requires lightening the old design first, especially if it's dark. The tattoo artist judges whether the base works.

Can a tattoo I only half regret just be faded?

Yes. Partial removal lightens a tattoo without aiming to make it disappear. It can make it more discreet, or prepare a cover-up.

Can I touch up a tattoo that has aged badly?

Yes, with a tattoo artist, if you still like the design. It's not a treatment we offer. A touch-up makes the tattoo more visible: it fits when you still love it, not when you want it to fade from view.

Sources

  • Armstrong ML et al. "Motivation for Contemporary Tattoo Removal: A Shift in Identity". Archives of Dermatology, 2008;144(7):879-884. Summary: news-medical.net
  • American Academy of Dermatology, "Tattoo removal: Lasers outshine other methods". aad.org
  • Cleveland Clinic, "Tattoo Removal". my.clevelandclinic.org

A question about your skin?

The best plan starts with an assessment. We look at your skin and answer your questions, no obligation.

Question 1/4

Your main concern?